This post contains affiliate links.
It can sometimes be tricky to decide what kind of nails to get because you have to evaluate how much one advantage weighs against the other’s disadvantage. There are so many things to consider, like the drying time, how long it will last, things you need to remove and what kind of finish you’re looking for. However, you’ll be glad to know that I’ve provided a detailed examination of both polishes so that you can have a complete comparison between nail lacquers and gel polishes.
Nail Lacquer and Gel Polish consist of different formulas. Nail Lacquers include solvents in the formula that allows the polish to form a film once it (the solvent) is evaporated. Gel nail polish on the other hand consists of photoinitiators that react to UV rays by bonding the chemicals inside the gel to make it harden.
Below, I will discuss in detail the differences between Nail Lacquer and Gel Nail Polish. I will analyze the difference in appearance, application styles, formula, drying, and removal methods. I will then describe what benefits and disadvantages of each you should look for to decide which of the polishes are more suitable for you.
Table of Contents
Difference In Appearance
When it comes to appearance at first glance, nail lacquers and gel polishes might look the same. However, upon closer inspection, you will find that gel polishes have a thicker look and feel. Nail polish is most widely known as it was the first one in the market.
It was so early on the market that it dates back to 3000 BC in China where it starts in very few colors that distinguished classes. However, a few experiments later and they were making different colors with vegetable dyes, egg whites, and beeswax.
For this reason, you will find that nail polishes possess a wider range of colors than gel polishes. Nail lacquers may also be more visually appealing as it gives off a spectacular gloss and shine when used on nails.
Gel polish, on the other hand, has a far briefer history as it came through the gradual evolution of nail polish but is a completely different product. You will find a great range of colors in gel polish but not as varied as nail lacquers. Gel Polishes are better known for the metallic colors that go well with their thick consistency.
They will appear hardened on your nails and smoother than nail lacquer would.
If I were to choose between the two based on appearance alone my choice would be the nail lacquers. But visual appeal varies among people. Those who prefer a smoother, more professional look may opt for gel polish.
It is suitable for formal spaces as it gives off less of a sheen than the lacquer while still maintaining a bit of an exciting element. For more casual spaces, nail lacquers can literally shine the most here. The vast colors are great accessories to get-ups and make-up choices.
The color and varnish alone can pick up or tone down your look depending on what you require. As it gives more room for styling options it would certainly be a personal preference.
Difference In Formula
Although both nail lacquers and gel polishes serve the purpose of polishing your fingernails, they are both different solutions. In fact, their formulas are quite different from each other.
The Nail Lacquer will include resins that provide the sheen element that we spoke earlier about. Resins come in all forms. They can be made from shellac which is actually a secretion from a lac insect that is found in the trees of forests. Shellac is not only used in nail polish; you will also find it in varnishing products. If you want to read more about shellac and the formula you can find it here.
You will even find it in your food – mostly candy. It Is what gives all these products their sheen and hardened layer which is exactly what you want in nail polish.
Nail Lacquers will also include film-forming agents such as nitrocellulose which gives nail polish its adhesivity. You will notice that when nail lacquer is applied to your nails it is wet and easily manipulated around your nail plate. However, once it dries, it can no longer be moved around or simply rubbed off as it could when it was initially applied.
The film-forming agent is what causes this. Once your nail is dried this means all the solvent is removed from the formula leaving the film over your nails.
Speaking of solvent, it is also a common ingredient in nail lacquers to act as the carrier. As we mentioned before, it is when the solvent is dried that the film is formed. You can imagine how difficult it would be to apply dry, fixed-film on the nails.
This is why your carrier solvent is needed and is the reason your nails take hours to dry. This solvent needs to be dried out for the film to form. This is different from your gel polish formula.
You will find that no matter how long you wait your gel polish isn’t drying. This is because it does not have a solvent like nail lacquers do. Gel nail polish contains photoinitiators that respond to UV light.
The light causes a chemical reaction in the nail polish that causes it to harden into the smooth polis